Saarinen Tulip chair and table: original, authorized reissue or replica?

Eero Saarinen's pedestal chairs and tables have been made by Knoll since the 1950s, and the form has been copied for nearly as long. Separating a period Knoll piece from current production or an unauthorized reproduction depends on materials, construction and marks, read together. Here is what to check, and what a photo can and cannot tell you.

A short history: who made it, and when

Eero Saarinen designed the Pedestal Collection, now widely called the Tulip collection, for Knoll in the mid-1950s. Sources give dates between 1955 and 1957: Knoll dates the collection to 1957, Cranbrook Art Museum gives 1955 to 1957, and LACMA records the armchair as designed around 1955 and manufactured from 1956.

Saarinen's stated aim was to clear away what he called the slum of legs under chairs and tables. The Victoria and Albert Museum records that the chair was first meant to be molded from a single piece of fiberglass, but a fiberglass base proved too weak to support a sitter, so aluminum was used for the stem. A 1957 Design magazine article quoted by the V&A has Saarinen saying he wanted to make the chair all one thing again.

Knoll has been the manufacturer from the start. Museum records name Knoll Associates and Knoll International, with production in East Greenville, Pennsylvania. Knoll says Florence Knoll invited Saarinen to design for the company in the 1940s, and Knoll still makes the chairs, stools and tables today.

What "original" means for Tulip pieces

A vintage piece is one Knoll made decades ago, typically labeled Knoll Associates or Knoll International. Current production is what Knoll makes and sells now, marked with a Knoll or KnollStudio logo and Saarinen's signature. Both are authorized Knoll pieces. LACMA describes the armchair as manufactured from 1956 to the present, so current production is a continuation, not a copy.

An unauthorized reproduction is a pedestal chair or table in this form made without Knoll's authorization. Quality ranges from obvious to very close, which is why no single feature should decide the question.

Model numbers help with descriptions. LACMA catalogs the Tulip armchair as model 150. A model number in a listing is a description, not proof.

The chair: shell, base and how they meet

On a Knoll chair, the seat shell and the stem are two different materials. Knoll specifies a molded fiberglass shell on a cast-aluminum base with a Rilsan finish, a coating Knoll describes as corrosion resistant. LACMA's record of a chair from about 1965 lists cast aluminum with a plastic coating and fiberglass-reinforced plastic, and auction catalogs often describe vintage bases as enameled aluminum.

That makes material the first thing to check. A chair whose shell and stem are one continuous piece of molded plastic is not the Knoll construction. The RealReal, quoting a Knoll specialist, notes that because the base is cast, an original is one piece of metal, while copies may show a seam, and that screws visible under the base of a chair are not expected on an original.

Look at the underside of the shell where it meets the top of the stem, and at the foot of the base from below. Photograph both straight on. Also note whether the chair swivels: Knoll offers both swivel and fixed versions today, and swivel chairs appear in vintage auction records, so either can be correct.

The seat cushion is a separate element on most chairs. Knoll's current version uses a foam seat pad in fabric or leather, with a fully upholstered option. Cushions are the part most often replaced, so a new cushion on an old chair is common and says little about the frame.

The table: base, top and underside

Knoll's current tables use a cast-aluminum base with a corrosion-resistant Rilsan finish, in black, white, cream or grey. Tops are offered in marble, granite, slate, quartz, laminate or wood veneer, and Knoll calls marble the classic choice. Round and oval tables run from a 35-inch cafe table to a 96-inch dining table.

Period tables appear in auction records with marble tops on white enameled or lacquered bases, and with labels on the underside. Turn the table on its side only if it is safe to do so. Marble tops are heavy, and a loose top can slide off the base.

Wear is normal on old tables. Auction condition reports for vintage Knoll tables mention chips and paint loss on the base, scratches and discoloration on marble, and corrosion under the base. Realistic wear in the places a table is touched and moved is consistent with age, but it can also be imitated, so it is supporting evidence rather than proof.

Labels, stamps and paperwork, and their limits

Current Knoll tables carry a stamped mark. Knoll states that the KnollStudio logo and Saarinen's signature are stamped into the bottom of the base, with placement varying by model, or on the base or underside of the top. Current chairs are described in auction listings as stamped with the KnollStudio logo and Saarinen's signature.

Vintage pieces were usually identified with labels rather than stamps. Auction catalogs record Knoll Associates or Knoll International labels on the underside of vintage pieces. The RealReal notes that Knoll's logo and the address printed on its labels changed over the decades, which can help date a piece if a label survives.

Labels can be lost, transferred or imitated, and stamps can be copied. A label also only shows that one component came from Knoll. A chair with an old shell on a later base, or a table with a replacement top, is possible. Treat every mark as one piece of evidence to weigh with the construction.

Common signs of an unauthorized reproduction

No single sign settles it, but some patterns justify a closer look. On chairs, these include a shell and base molded as one plastic piece, a base that feels light or hollow, a visible seam along the stem, and screws or bolts exposed on the underside of the base.

On tables, look for a base that is not cast metal or that shows a seam, and a top material that Knoll did not offer for the period claimed. A piece sold as current Knoll production with no stamp anywhere, or a vintage label that does not fit the claimed date, should also be checked further.

Price is context, not evidence. A price far below the usual market for a piece of the claimed age and condition is a reason to look harder at everything else.

What to photograph for a preliminary check

Clear photos let us compare the construction details that separate Knoll pieces from copies. Use daylight or bright, even light, avoid filters, and keep each detail in focus. For a table, photograph the underside without lifting a heavy top if that is unsafe.

A photo review can point toward vintage Knoll, current production, an unauthorized reproduction, or inconclusive. It cannot weigh the base or test the materials by hand, so some pieces will need an in-person inspection before anyone can give a firmer view.

  • The whole chair or table from the front and the side, at eye level.
  • The underside of the chair shell, showing where it meets the stem.
  • The underside of the base, straight on, showing any stamp, label, screws or seams.
  • The full length of the stem, in raking light, to show any seam line.
  • The shell edge and surface close up, to show the material and finish.
  • For a table, the underside of the top and the join between top and base.
  • For a table, the edge of the top close up, and the top surface in good light.
  • Any label, decal, tag or stamp, straight on and readable.
  • The seat cushion, top and underside, including any upholstery label.
  • Any receipt, invoice or paperwork that came with the piece.

Frequently asked questions

Who is authorized to make the Tulip chair and table?

Knoll. Saarinen designed the Pedestal Collection for Knoll in the mid-1950s, and museum records name Knoll Associates and Knoll International as manufacturers. Knoll still produces it today.

What is a Knoll Tulip chair made of?

Knoll specifies a molded fiberglass shell on a cast-aluminum base with a Rilsan finish. Saarinen first wanted a one-piece fiberglass chair, but the fiberglass base was too weak, so aluminum was used for the stem.

Where is the Knoll stamp on a Tulip table?

On current tables, Knoll says the logo and Saarinen's signature are stamped into the bottom of the base or on the underside of the top, depending on the model. Vintage tables more often have a paper or decal label underneath.

Is a Tulip chair without a label a fake?

Not necessarily. Labels on vintage pieces are often lost over the decades. A missing label is a missing clue, so the shell, base and construction need to be assessed instead.

Is a one-piece plastic Tulip chair a Knoll original?

No. Knoll's construction pairs a fiberglass shell with a separate cast-aluminum base. A chair molded as a single plastic piece is not the Knoll design.

Can photos prove a Tulip chair or table is original?

No. Photos can support a preliminary opinion based on materials, construction and marks, and sometimes the honest answer is inconclusive. Certainty may require an in-person inspection.

Not sure about your piece?

Send us your photos for a preliminary opinion, from EUR 79. We reply by email with a quote before any work starts.

Sources

  1. Knoll: Tulip Chair, Armless
  2. Knoll: Saarinen Dining Table, Round
  3. Knoll: Saarinen Dining Table Collection
  4. Knoll: Designer Eero Saarinen
  5. Victoria and Albert Museum: Tulip armchair, Eero Saarinen
  6. Cranbrook Art Museum: Eero Saarinen, Pedestal or Tulip Side Chair
  7. LACMA: Pedestal (Tulip) armchair, model 150
  8. Sotheby's: Eero Saarinen, Knoll, Tulip armchair
  9. Brunk Auctions: Eero Saarinen for Knoll coffee table with marble top
  10. Bukowskis: Eero Saarinen, dining table, Tulip, Knoll International
  11. The RealReal: The unusual story behind Knoll furniture