Noguchi coffee table: original, authorized reissue or replica?

Isamu Noguchi's glass-top coffee table, known as the IN-50, looks simple enough that it is widely copied. Genuine examples include tables made by Herman Miller from 1947, current Herman Miller production and Vitra's European edition. This guide explains what to examine, what the marks do and do not prove, and what to photograph for a preliminary check.

A short history: from the Goodyear table to Herman Miller and Vitra

Noguchi's first table was a 1939 commission from A. Conger Goodyear, then president of the Museum of Modern Art, made of rosewood and glass. The Noguchi Museum's catalogue raisonné records that table separately, and it is a one-off, not the production model.

The production coffee table, IN-50, is dated 1944 by The Noguchi Museum. According to the museum's chronology, Herman Miller manufactured it as part of George Nelson's first collection in 1947 and included it in the 1948 catalogue. The museum gives its production dates as 1947 to 1973 and 1984 to the present, after Herman Miller reintroduced it.

In Europe, Vitra states that it has produced re-editions of Noguchi designs since 2002 in cooperation with the Isamu Noguchi Foundation in New York, and it sells the table as the Coffee Table. Herman Miller's retail pages describe its table as the authentic Noguchi Table, and the company lists Noguchi among its registered trademarks.

Herman Miller's own materials are not always consistent about the design date, citing 1947 or 1948 in different places. For a dated history, the museum's 1944 design date and 1947 production start are the most authoritative.

What 'original' means for a Noguchi table

A vintage table, in the usual sense, is one made by Herman Miller during the first production run, from 1947 to 1973. A table made by Herman Miller since 1984, or by Vitra since 2002, is current production or an authorized reissue. All of these are genuine.

An unauthorized reproduction is a table made to look like the IN-50 by anyone other than the licensed manufacturers. The design is simple in outline, two wooden legs, a rod and a sheet of glass, so the quality of copies varies a great deal. A careful copy can look right in a room photo.

Components can also be mixed. A genuine base may carry a replacement top, or an old top may sit on a newer base. That does not make the table fake, but it matters for value and it is one reason to assess the glass and base separately.

The glass top: thickness, shape and edge

The top is a thick, free-form sheet of glass that rests on the base without being fixed to it, as the Victoria and Albert Museum notes. Current Herman Miller tables use 3/4 inch (about 19 mm) glass, and Vitra lists 19 mm glass with ground, rounded edges.

Early tops are commonly reported to have been thicker. Reference sources drawing on Leslie Pina's Classic Herman Miller state that the first tops were 7/8 inch (about 22 mm) plate glass and that the thickness was reduced to 3/4 inch in 1965. Treat this as a useful clue rather than proof, and measure the thickness at the edge rather than estimating it from a photo.

Older plate glass often shows a green tint when seen edge-on, and auction houses have described early examples as sold with their 'original green glass'. Modern glass can also look green at the edge, so the tint on its own does not date a top.

The outline matters more than many owners expect. The top is an irregular, rounded shape with no straight edges, and The Noguchi Museum lists the table at about 50 by 36 inches. A top noticeably smaller, more oval or more symmetrical than this is worth comparing carefully against a known genuine example.

The base: two identical legs and the pivot rod

The base is made of two identical solid wood pieces, one turned and set against the other, meeting at a single narrow point where they are joined by a rod. The Victoria and Albert Museum describes them as two pivoting forms set inversely to each other. Both legs should have the same profile; a mismatch suggests replacement or a copy.

Base woods changed over time. Early Herman Miller tables were made in walnut and birch, and reference sources citing Pina report cherry in the first year only and birch discontinued after 1954. The Victoria and Albert Museum dates its birch-based example to roughly 1947 to 1955. Ebonized bases are reported in later production. Today Herman Miller offers black poplar, walnut, white ash and white oak, and Vitra offers black ash, maple and walnut.

The pivot is a short rod running through both legs. Herman Miller's current assembly instructions describe a dowel rod with small pins that seat in slots milled into the legs, which fixes the legs at an angle of 52 degrees. Older tables may differ: one early birch table sold at auction was described with a straight aluminum pin. A loose pivot on an old table is common and repairable.

Look at the wood itself. On solid wood the grain should run continuously over the curved surfaces and around the edges. Veneer edges, visible layers on the ends of the legs, or a painted finish over an indistinct material are worth asking about.

Signatures, medallions and their limits

Current Herman Miller tables carry Noguchi's signature in two places: etched along the longest edge of the glass top and on a medallion mounted to the underside of the lower leg. Herman Miller presents these as marks of authenticity, and its assembly instructions show the signature medallion on the bottom of the lower leg.

Marks on vintage tables are less consistent. Auction descriptions of early Herman Miller tables, including the ones cited below, generally record the wood, glass and hardware but no signature. When and how the etched signature and medallion were introduced is not clearly documented in the sources we reviewed, so an unsigned top does not by itself mean a table is a copy.

Signatures can also be imitated, and a replacement top may carry no signature or a different one from the base. Check that any etching looks crisp and permanent rather than printed or stuck on, and that marks on the glass and base are consistent with each other and with the rest of the table.

Receipts from an authorized retailer, the original packaging or the assembly sheet help with recent tables. For vintage tables, provenance such as an estate record or an old photograph of the table in a home carries more weight than any single mark.

Common signs of an unauthorized reproduction

No single feature proves a table is a copy, but some combinations should make you cautious. Glass noticeably thinner than 3/4 inch, a top with flat or sharp edges, legs that differ from each other, a base made of veneered panels, or a pivot that is a simple bolt with visible nuts all deserve closer inspection.

Proportions are another clue. Genuine tables are about 15 3/4 inches high in current production, with the top about 50 by 36 inches. A table that looks right but sits noticeably lower, higher or with a smaller top may be a reproduction or a mismatched set.

Listings that say 'Noguchi style', 'inspired by' or 'IN-50 type' are usually not claiming licensed manufacture. Treat a missing signature, a price well below the usual range and no close-up photos of the base and glass edge as reasons to ask more questions.

What to photograph for a preliminary check

Photos can show proportions, the shape of the legs, the pivot, edge profiles and marks. They cannot measure glass thickness precisely, confirm a wood species with certainty or show what is hidden inside the joint. A preliminary opinion from photos is a starting point, not a guarantee. Use daylight and include a tape measure where you can.

  • The whole table from above, with the full outline of the glass visible
  • The whole table from the side at floor level, showing both legs
  • The base with the glass removed, from two angles
  • A close-up of the pivot point and rod where the two legs meet
  • The end grain and edges of each leg, close up
  • The edge of the glass with a ruler or tape measure held against it to show thickness
  • The longest edge of the glass, looking for any etched signature
  • The underside of both legs, including any medallion, label or stamp
  • Overall height and the length and width of the top, measured with a tape
  • Any receipts, packaging, assembly sheets or provenance notes

Frequently asked questions

When was the Noguchi table designed?

The Noguchi Museum dates the IN-50 coffee table to 1944. Herman Miller began manufacturing it in 1947. An earlier one-off rosewood table for A. Conger Goodyear dates from 1939.

Was the Noguchi table ever out of production?

Yes. According to The Noguchi Museum, Herman Miller discontinued it in 1973 and reintroduced it in 1984. It has been in production since then.

Is the Vitra Noguchi coffee table authentic?

Yes. Vitra says it has produced re-editions of Noguchi designs since 2002 in cooperation with the Isamu Noguchi Foundation. It is authorized current production, not a replica.

How thick is the glass on a real Noguchi table?

Current Herman Miller and Vitra tops are 3/4 inch, about 19 mm. Early Herman Miller tops are reported to have been 7/8 inch, about 22 mm, before a change in the mid-1960s.

Does every authentic Noguchi table have a signature?

Current Herman Miller tables are signed on the glass edge and on a base medallion. Many vintage tables are unmarked, so a missing signature on an older table is not proof of a copy.

Not sure about your piece?

Send us your photos for a preliminary opinion, from EUR 79. We reply by email with a quote before any work starts.

Sources

  1. The Noguchi Museum: Chronology
  2. The Noguchi Museum: Noguchi Subscapes, Coffee Table (IN-50) for Herman Miller
  3. The Isamu Noguchi Catalogue Raisonné: Table for A. Conger Goodyear [162]
  4. Victoria and Albert Museum: Noguchi Table (IN-50), W.1:1, 2-2010
  5. Herman Miller: Noguchi Table
  6. Herman Miller: Noguchi Table Assembly Instructions (2017, retailer-hosted PDF)
  7. Design Within Reach: Noguchi Table
  8. Vitra: Coffee Table, Isamu Noguchi
  9. Wright: Isamu Noguchi, coffee table model IN-50 (March 2008)
  10. Billings: Isamu Noguchi, Early IN-50 Coffee Table
  11. Wikipedia: Noguchi table (glass thickness and base woods, citing Pina, Classic Herman Miller)